Call now: 252-767-6166  
Oracle Training Oracle Support Development Oracle Apps

 
 Home
 E-mail Us
 Oracle Articles
New Oracle Articles


 Oracle Training
 Oracle Tips

 Oracle Forum
 Class Catalog


 Remote DBA
 Oracle Tuning
 Emergency 911
 RAC Support
 Apps Support
 Analysis
 Design
 Implementation
 Oracle Support


 SQL Tuning
 Security

 Oracle UNIX
 Oracle Linux
 Monitoring
 Remote s
upport
 Remote plans
 Remote
services
 Application Server

 Applications
 Oracle Forms
 Oracle Portal
 App Upgrades
 SQL Server
 Oracle Concepts
 Software Support

 Remote S
upport  
 Development  

 Implementation


 Consulting Staff
 Consulting Prices
 Help Wanted!

 


 Oracle Posters
 Oracle Books

 Oracle Scripts
 Ion
 Excel-DB  

Don Burleson Blog 


 

 

 


 

 

 
 


Oracle composite index column ordering

Expert Oracle Database Tips by Donald BurlesonConsulting

August 16, 2015

Question:  I have a SQL with multiple columns in my where clause.  I know that Oracle can only choose one index, and I know about multi-column composite indexes, but I do not know how to determine the optimal column order for a composite index with multiple column values.  What is the secret for creating a composite index with the columns in the proper sequence?

Answer: You are correct that the column sequence matters!  This is an empirical question, and you need to run diagnostic scripts against your SQL workload (STATSPACK or AWR) to examine how frequently a specific index column was needed by SQL.  Remember, it's the SQL workload that drives your choice of composite indexes, and the order of the columns within the index.

See these important scripts to display multi-column index usage using AWR.

  • In general, when using a multi-column index, you want to put the most restrictive column value first (the column with the highest unique values) because this will trim-down the result set.
  • Because Oracle can only access one index, your job is to examine your historical SQL workload and build a single composite index that satisfies the majority of the SQL queries.
  • The Oracle optimizer may try to make single column  indexes behave as-if they were a single composite index.  Prior to 10g, this could be done with the "and_equal" hint.
  • Beware that indexes have overhead and see my notes on detecting duplicate index columns.
  • You can run scripts to monitor the invocation count for each column in a multiple column composite index (see counting column usage from a SQL workload) 

I have more complete details on composite index usage monitoring in my book Advanced Oracle SQL Tuning: The Definitive Reference.  Also, see my related notes on tuning with composite bitmap indexes and my scripts to monitor which columns of a composite index are used, and counting index column usage from AWR and STATSPACK.   

Large Multi-column Composite Indexes

Multi-column indexes with more than 3 columns may not provide more efficient access than a two-column index.  The objective of the index is to reduce the amount of rows returned from a table access.  Therefore each added column must substantially reduce the number of returned rows to be effective.  For example, assuming a large table, on a query with 5 or more WHERE (AND) clauses using a 5-column index may return only 1 row.  However using a 3-column index may return only 50 rows.  A two-column index returns 200 rows.  The time it takes to extract the one row from the 200 rows using nested-loops is negligible. 

Thus the two-column index may be almost as efficient (fast) as the 5-column index.  The key is to index the most restrictive columns.  Another tradeoff is a table with multiple column indexes where the leading column(s) are the same.  For instance, a table with four 3-column indexes where the leading two columns are the same may work very efficiently on select statements but cause a heavy penalty on inserts and updates.  Just one 2-column index on the leading two columns may provide acceptable query performance while greatly improving DML.

Small tables with two or three columns may benefit by being rebuilt as an Index Organized Table (IOT).  A 2-column table with a primary key and a two-column index has 1.5 times the data in indexes that are in the table.  Making the table an Index Organized Table reduced the need for indexes because the table is the index.  Also IOTs can have indexes on non-leading columns if required.   Again this has to be balanced with the overhead of maintaining the IOT.

Lastly, do not be afraid to use temporary indexes.  If you run a nightly report that requires 6 hours to run, but will run in 30 mins with a specific index, you might want to create the index before running the report and drop it upon completion.  I work with clients that drop certain indexes to expedite the bill run, then recreate then for the normal application.  They create indexes each night and drop them in the morning.  There is nothing wrong with dynamically changing you database to respond to varying tasks if it results in efficiency.

 

Script for tracking composite index column usage

These scripts will only track SQL that you have directed Oracle to capture via your threshold settings in AWR or STATSPACK. STATSPACK and AWR will not collect "transient SQL" that did not appear in v$sql at snapshot time.  Hence, not all SQL will appear in these reports.  See my notes here on adjusting the SQL capture thresholds.

          index_usage_hr.sql

 
col c1 heading 'Begin|Interval|time' format a20
col c2 heading 'Search Columns'      format 999
col c3 heading 'Invocation|Count'    format 99,999,999
 
 
break on c1 skip 2
 
accept idxname char prompt 'Enter Index Name: '
 
ttitle 'Invocation Counts for index|&idxname'
 
select
   to_char(sn.begin_interval_time,'yy-mm-dd hh24')  c1,
   p.search_columns                                 c2,
   count(*)                                         c3
from
SEE CODE DEPOT FOR FULL SCRIPTS
   dba_hist_snapshot  sn,
   dba_hist_sql_plan   p,
   dba_hist_sqlstat   st
where
   st.sql_id = p.sql_id
and
   sn.snap_id = st.snap_id   
and   
   p.object_name = '&idxname'
group by
   begin_interval_time,search_columns;
 

The query will produce an output showing a summary count of the index specified during the snapshot interval. This can be compared to the number of times that a table was invoked from SQL.  Here is a sample of the output from the script.

 
Invocation Counts for cust_index
 
 
Begin
Interval                             Invocation
time                 Search Columns       Count
-------------------- -------------- -----------
04-10-21 15                       1           3
04-10-10 16                       0           1
04-10-10 19                       1           1
04-10-11 02                       0           2
04-10-11 04                       2           1
04-10-11 06                       3           1
04-10-11 11                       0           1
04-10-11 12                       0           2
04-10-11 13                       2           1
04-10-11 15                       0           3
04-10-11 17                       0          14
04-10-11 18                       4           1
04-10-11 19                       0           1
04-10-11 20                       3           7
04-10-11 21                       0           1

For more complete details on creating a custom composite index monitoring infrastructure, see my latest book Advanced Oracle SQL Tuning: The Definitive Reference.

 
Get the Complete
Oracle SQL Tuning Information 

The landmark book "Advanced Oracle SQL Tuning  The Definitive Reference"  is filled with valuable information on Oracle SQL Tuning. This book includes scripts and tools to hypercharge Oracle 11g performance and you can buy it for 30% off directly from the publisher.

 

 

Burleson is the American Team

Note: This Oracle documentation was created as a support and Oracle training reference for use by our DBA performance tuning consulting professionals.  Feel free to ask questions on our Oracle forum.

Verify experience! Anyone considering using the services of an Oracle support expert should independently investigate their credentials and experience, and not rely on advertisements and self-proclaimed expertise. All legitimate Oracle experts publish their Oracle qualifications.

Errata?  Oracle technology is changing and we strive to update our BC Oracle support information.  If you find an error or have a suggestion for improving our content, we would appreciate your feedback.  Just  e-mail:  and include the URL for the page.


                    









Burleson Consulting

The Oracle of Database Support

Oracle Performance Tuning

Remote DBA Services


 

Copyright © 1996 -  2016

All rights reserved by Burleson

Oracle ® is the registered trademark of Oracle Corporation.


 

��  
 
 
Oracle Training at Sea
 
 
 
 
oracle dba poster
 

 
Follow us on Twitter 
 
Oracle performance tuning software 
 
Oracle Linux poster